- Snavely
- Snell
- Snider
- Snyder
- Soles
- Soliday
- Solomon
- Sommer
- Sotdorus
- Sowers
- Spalding
- Ann (28 May 1786 - 3 Feb 1841)
- Span
- Spangler
- Spears
- Mary (4 May 1816 - 19 Feb 1881)
- Spessart
- Sponseller
- Spring
- Sprinkle
- St. Clair
- Stably
- Stagner
- Stahl
- Stambaugh
- Standiford
- Stansbauch
- Stansbury
- Starmer
- Starner
- Staub
- Stauffer
- Steel
- Steele
- Steffie
- Barbara (22 May 1790 - 28 Aug 1866)
- Stegner
- Steinbarger
- Steiner
- Stengle
- Stermer
- Joseph (31 Dec 1832 - 5 May 1913)
- Sterner